In our society we have become so accustomed to silly and frivilous lawsuits that we seem to sometimes just accept them. It seems that these days, the first response is to sue over anything. Whether it is an appropriate lawsuit doesn't seem to be a question. This time around, a group of 25 Greek Lawyers, (yes, Lawyers) are suing Warner Brothers over their portrayal of Alexander the Great in their recent critically panned movie Alexander as bisexual.
Yes, you heard me right, lawyers are suing over the portrayal of a character in a movie.
The lawyer leading the campaign, Yannis Varnakos, said the impending suit is not an attack against gays, but rather a demand to make the film historically accurate.
"We cannot come out and say that President John F. Kennedy was a shooting guard for the Los Angeles Lakers basketball team and so Warner cannot come out and say Alexander was gay," Varnakos told Reuters.
Although Varnakos had not yet seen the film, he claimed there was enough evidence to point to the film's inaccurate references.
There are so many things wrong here. First of all, why are they demanding that the film be made historically accurate? Since when are films based on a historical premise required to be historically accurate? Most, if not all, historical movies take many liberties with the plot and characterizations to adapt a historical story into a film context or even add things to it. People are allowed to adapt history in whatever way they want to make a film. People may not like the film because of it, but filmmakers are allowed to do whatever they want regardless of historical accuracy. Of course, this argument is even more ridiculous because they ignore the fact that many historians and scholars do think that Alexander the Great was indeed bisexual. Will they also sue any other historians who disagree with them
As to their point that people couldn't come out and say that JFK was a player for the Lakers, I have one thing to say - bullshit. I have a reality check for these lawyers - in our society there is a thing called free speech which allows people to say whatever they want, regardless of what others think. (I am not sure what exactly the specifics are on speech laws in Greece, but I'm pretty sure that it would be similar.) I could write a book which claims that JFK played for the Lakers and claim that it's true and nobody could justifiably sue me over it. People would just think that I'm full of it. Nobody can stop me from claiming whatever I want; they can only disagree.
As an aside, I think a movie about JFK being a pro basketball player would be a cool concept. Somebody should make it just to piss these Greek lawyers off.
Lastly, this whole thing is taken to an even higher level of ridiculous irrelevance because they haven't even seen the movie they are complaining about.
So, to the twenty-five Greek lawyers I say this - do your homework on Alexander and more importantly on free speech.
[Thanks to Posté for the link]